Diagnosis and Treatment
Diagnosing moderate and severe traumatic brain injuries (TBI) is relatively simple. The patient will have specific symptoms and/or signs associated with this type of injury (abnormal CT/MRI findings, loss of consciousness for more than 30 minutes, symptoms that do not go away), as well as physical evidence of the injury (open wounds, epilepsy, etc).
Diagnosing a mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI), on the other hand, presents a greater challenge because many patients may not have any visible physical signs, or the signs they do have will not be as notorious as moderate or severe brain injuries. Rather, many patients will present disabling cognitive, psychological, behavioral impairments, and/or employment disabilities that may go unnoticed for several days, weeks, months, or, in some cases, even longer. In other words, a mild traumatic brain injury may not be diagnosed until the individual begins to have problems in what were once easy tasks or social situations. For this reason, a mild traumatic brain injury is referred to as the “silent epidemic” or the “invisible injury.”
Persons seeking medical attention as a result of a mild traumatic brain injury will generally receive only a standard history and a physical exam based on subjective complains. In those cases, further imaging such as head Computerized Tomography (CT) or possibly Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) will be obtained only if the patient has loss of consciousness, posttraumatic amnesia, focal neurological deficits, or physical signs of a skull fracture if the cause of the injury is an indicator as to the severity of the injury, or the particular circumstances require further medical examination.
However, this method may not be specific enough to identify individuals who have suffered a mild traumatic brain injury because:
- Neurological tests as well as the subjective complaints or symptoms can be influenced or “tainted” by numerous demographic, situational, preexisting, co-occurring and injury related factors;1
- The subjective nature of the complaints and the significant overlap with other conditions (e.g. Post-traumatic stress disorder);2 and
- Due to the diffuse and subtle nature of mild brain injury, it is common for typical neuroimaging (CT scan or MRIs) to show no evidence of the injury. The limitation of these brain imaging technologies is that they often cannot detect mild brain injury. The reason for that is because a mild brain injury can often damage the white matter of the brain, and white matter consists of the axons of neurons (connections) in the brain which is much harder to capture or visualize using common types of brain imaging.3
In addition, this subjective symptom-based approach has led to several patients with mild traumatic brain injuries to be underdiagnosed. A University of Washington study demonstrated a 56% diagnosis rate of traumatic brain injuries in the emergency room setting.4
The numbers speak for themselves. Diagnosing mild traumatic brain injuries relying solely on subjective evaluations and typical neuroimaging (CT scans or MRIs) can lead to traumatic brain injury misdiagnosis. Therefore, it is highly advisable to consider both the subjective complains of the patient as well as objective findings, including new technology capable of bringing out evidence of mild traumatic brain injury, so that it can be properly diagnosed and treated, thus, increasing the probability of recovery.
Currently, the most common systems that medical practitioners initially use to bring out evidence of traumatic brain injury are the Glasgow Coma Scale and the Ranchos Los Amigos Scale.
The Glasgow Coma Scale is based on a 15-point scale for estimating and categorizing the outcomes of brain injury on the basis of overall social capability or dependence on others. The test measures the motor response, verbal response, and eye opening response with the following values:
I. Motor Response
6 – Obeys commands fully
5 – Localizes to noxious stimuli
4 – Withdraws from noxious stimuli
3 – Abnormal flexion, i.e. decorticate posturing
2 – Extensor response, i.e. decerebrate posturing
1 – No response
II. Verbal Response
5 – Alert and Oriented
4 – Confused, yet coherent, speech
3 – Inappropriate words and jumbled phrases consisting of words
2 – Incomprehensible sounds
1 – No sounds
III. Eye Opening
4 – Spontaneous eye opening
3 – Eyes open to speech
2 – Eyes open to pain
1 – No eye opening
The final score is determined by adding the values of I+II+III. This number helps doctors and medical practitioners categorize severity of the brain injury as Mild (13-15), Moderate (9-12), and Severe (8-3).
Ranchos Los Amigos Scale
Measures the levels of awareness, cognition, behavior and interaction with the environment.
Level I: No Response
Level II: Generalized Response
Level III: Localized Response
Level IV: Confused-agitated
Level V: Confused-inappropriate
Level VI: Confused-appropriate
Level VII: Automatic-appropriate
Level VIII: Purposeful-appropriate
Over the years, modern medicine has developed several tests to determine with reasonable medical certainty whether a person has suffered a traumatic brain injury, such as CAT and MRI scans, SWI (Susceptibility Weighted Imaging), Diffusion Tensor Imaging (DTI), Magnetic Resonance Angiography (MRA), Electroencephalogram (EEG), Quantitative EEG, Position Emission Tomography (PET) scan, Single Photon Emission Computed Tomography (SPECT), lumbar puncture, and Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy (MRS).
There is also new technology for diagnosing traumatic brain injury in the form of tests which measure the extent of the physical trauma that the brain suffered by looking at the body response to such injury, such as bleeding in the brain or markers in the bloodstream.
The FDA has approved a battery-powered device called the InfraScanner, developed by the Office of Naval Research (ONR).5 When there is bleeding in the brain as a result of an injury, there will be pools of blood in the brain which absorb and reflect light differently than normal brain tissue. By shinning a particular wavelength of light onto different parts of the head, the device can spot life-threatening bleeds or hematomas.6
In addition, scientists are also trying to find ways to spot changes in blood chemistry which are specific to brain injuries. This is done through biomarkers tests which indicate the presence of some disease or injury. Biomarkers, reflecting a biological response to injury or disease, have proven useful for the diagnosis of many pathological conditions including cancer, heart failure, infection, and genetic disorders.7
In the traumatic brain injury context, there are specific biomarkers in the cerebrospinal fluid and serum, such as BB isozyme of creatine kinase (CK-BB, predominant in brain), glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP), myelin basic protein (MBP), neuron-specific enolase (NSE), and S100B.8 The presence of these biomarkers may be helpful to diagnose persons with mild TBI where other tests and procedure are not successful in that regard.
There are several methods, procedures and tests to determine whether a person has sustained a traumatic brain injury. However, even though most of these test have proven to be extremely effective regarding moderate to severe traumatic brain injury, they are not as effective when the injury is mild, which can lead to misdiagnosis issues.
1 Recommendations for Diagnosis a Mild Traumatic Brain Injury: A National Academy of Neuropsychology Education Paper.
what our clients are saying
“This is a great firm that I highly recommend. They are very responsive, attentive, and aggressive in their representation of you. The attorneys and staff will fight hard for you! ”Jennifer Shanahan
“I have performed work for the Amaro Law Firm in support of their recent move to their new location. Such a pleasant staff! All friendly & so very helpful! Great attitudes! A wonderful group of folks to work with and for! ”Herb Zieschang
“I have known the Amaro firm for many years, and have had many great experiences with them. I have referred clients to them that have also had great experiences, and rave about how hard the Amaro firm worked for them. The Amaro firm is my number one firm to go to for anything including personal injury claims, business disputes, insurance claims, hurricane claims, and commercial litigation. ”Travis Funkhouser
“Amaro Law Firm has great customer service. They are very professional and alway a pleasure to work with. Mr. Amaro has a great team especially Wendy. They are very dedicated employees. ”Regena Ratcliff
“I have had the pleasure of working with Mr. Amaro and his team for over 5 years. He and his staff are always so pleasant and professional. ”Amber Epperson
“I was very fortunate to be able to work with David Miller of the Amaro Law Firm. They went above and beyond what other attorneys were willing to do to get the maximum recovery they could for their clients. I would highly recommend them to anyone for any type of case. ”Venetia Varden
“They care greatly about the experience their clients have, when calling their business. Clients are treated with the utmost respect by the Amaro Law Firm. They take the time to really address their concerns and problems, effective and accurately. ”Kelly Cammack
“ We have had the pleasure of working with the Amaro Law Firm recently.... I have found the Mr. Amaro and the entire Amaro Law Firm staff to be friendly, knowledgeable, fair and always available to speak with us when we need them.... I would highly recommend the Amaro Law Firm to my friends, colleagues and family! Thanks for being there for us Amaro Law Firm! It's nice to have people we can trust and depend on!!! Brett M. Downey, D.C. Fairview Health Center ”Fairview Health Center
“ Satisfied client I chose Amaro Law Firm after an insurance company tried to take advantage of me. As soon as I spoke to one of the representatives I automatically felt comfortable and confident that I was going to be taken care of. They communicated all plans and any changes during the process and most of all they were always honest. I was extremely happy with the settlement and would recommend them to anyone who wants results. Thank you Amaro Law Firm for the great customer service and for taking action! ”A client
“”Joe T Olvera
“ Great experience! James was very knowledgeable, responsive and was always accessible to answer my questions and concerns. I will definitely work with his firm again. Thank you! ”Scott
“I highly recommend Amaro Law Firm! The entire team at the firm are knowledgeable and courteous, and most importantly, get the job done! These guys are not afraid of trial cases, and will fight until the end. Thanks guys! You're the best! ”Kenneth Akiri
“ Satisfied client, I was very pleased on how fast he settled my case and the amount. I will refer my friends and family, thank you Amaro Law Firm . ”Rosie Navarrette
“Amaro law firm did an outstanding job getting me the most money for my insurance claim. They always kept me well informed and provided me with a great case manager!! ”Alberto Flores
“ The Amaro Law Firm is not afraid to pick a fight with money hungry insurance companies. In my case, they were extremely professional and achieved results that I thought were totally out of reach. I highly recommend this firm. ”R. L.
“ Best Lawyer in H-Town! Mr Amaro is the lawyer to have on your side when it comes to understanding your client's needs. He fought to give us the best result, highly recommended. ”Sam Barroso
“ I highly recommend the Amaro Law Firm. The attorneys and staff are attentive, professional and GREAT at what they do. It was been a pleasure to work with them, and they get GREAT results! Give them a call, you won't be disappointed!! ”Jennifer Sindelar Shanahan
“Excellent knowledgeable attorneys with helpful and patient staff. Zealous advocates for their clients' rights and interests. You want these guys on your side. ”Kristen Osborne
“ Thank you to the Amaro Law Firm. Professional and courteous the whole way through. I recommend anyone who is need of legal assistance to contact Amaro Law Firm. Kept in such good communication with me as well as follow ups. Truly a great team! ”Nicholas Carter
“The professionals at The Amaro Law Firm are talented, responsive and always fight for the best results for their clients. I have worked together with this firm over the past several years, and always have had a positive experience. ”Alan Quiles
“ The Amaro Law Firm Peer Review James Amaro is a very knowledgable and thorough lawyer. He puts his clients' interests first. He will help you in your time of need. ”Jeff Greco
“ Hard worker who goes the extra mile for his clients! I have worked with James for many years now and I am always blown away about his dedication to his firm. He truly cares about his staff and clients. Great guy and a very knowledgeable attorney. ”Kris Cox
“ The Amaro Law Firm was very thorough and fast in resolving my claim, I would recommend their service. ”L. D.
“ James is a great resource for me when it comes to case analysis, trial strategy, and responding to legal issues. He is a great person to help think of different way to present cases or to handle complex issues. ”A Private Practice Attorney
“Great to do business with them, good service! ”Abid Sattani
“After choosing the Amaro Law Firm it was evident that I had made the right decision in hiring them! They have been wonderful to work with. Always keeping me up to date with the progress of my claim and answering any questions that I may have. I would definitely recommend the Amaro Law Firm for anyone that wants a company that will stand up for them and work hard for what is theirs. ”Katherine Sirmon
“ My case was a sucess My attorney Mr. James Amaro was spectacular during my entire case. His staff and office were always very helpful and always made sure to answer all my questions during my legal process. I am very happy with the settlement of my case and how aggressive he was against the insurance companies who were not willing to settle before mediation. ”Don
“ Great lawyerEve
James worked so hard for me..great guy listen when I had questions about my case....Very honest I trust him with my life....He did what he said he would do for me and won a big case.....Thank you James........ ”